British households and businesses are paying some of the highest energy prices in the developed world. My new paper for the Prosperity Institute, ‘Not Zero: How Green Taxes Put British Energy Bills in the Red’, shows that a large part of the problem is self-inflicted. Carbon taxes and related levies — the Climate Change Levy (including Carbon Price Support), the UK Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) and Fuel Duty — now extract around £28 billion a year from the real economy. These charges fall especially heavily on mineral extraction, manufacturing, transport and agriculture, the foundational sectors that support the rest of the economy. Carbon taxes act as a brake on all businesses that produce basic materials, manufacture goods or transport physical goods, effectively blocking any attempt at reindustrialisation.
The paper finds that industrial energy consumption has almost halved since 2003, largely through deindustrialisation rather than efficiency gains. Overall energy use has fallen by a fifth since 2005 while per-capita GDP growth has pretty much stagnated. Britain has reduced its energy consumption by more than other comparable countries and growth has been slower than all but Canada. Electricity-sector productivity, measured by output per hour worked, has more than halved. Carbon costs embedded in wholesale power prices have frequently added £20–40 per megawatt-hour. Household electricity bills been driven sharply higher by carbon taxes and subsidies. Consumer energy debt and arrears have soared to almost £5 billion.
Abolishing the main rates of the Climate Change Levy, Carbon Price Support and the UK ETS would cut energy users’ bills by £7.2 billion a year — equivalent to around £250 per household, including about £60 directly off domestic energy bills. The gross cost to the Exchequer would be £4.2 billion, so energy users would gain almost £2 for every £1 of receipts the Treasury gives up. The paper estimates a long-run GDP boost of £5.7 billion a year (up to £7.4 billion in the upper case) from higher investment and more hours worked. Cutting other Net Zero spending such as EV subsidies and non-nuclear parts of GB Energy and the extra tax revenue from faster growth would offset much of the fiscal impact.
This is the opposite of the direction implied by the Prime Minister’s EU Reset. Linking the UK Emissions Trading Scheme to the EU’s would force British carbon prices up by around 32% to converge with higher European levels, raising costs across the economy. Participation in the EU electricity market would require dynamic alignment with EU rules, acceptance of the European Court of Justice as arbiter of disputes, and contributions to EU funds. The paper notes that any modest savings on imported power would be outweighed by these costs and by the loss of control over energy policy. The UK would also be tied to an EU target of achieving 42.5% of total energy from renewables by 2030 that is unachievable on current trajectories.
A UK Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), due to start in 2027, would not revive the industries that have already closed (e.g. ammonia and aluminium) and would raise costs for remaining downstream manufacturers while exempting many imported finished goods. Repealing the ETS, by contrast, would save energy users far more than the potential CBAM exposure over the rest of the decade.
The Reset is presented as a route to greater security and lower bills through closer European cooperation. The evidence in Not Zero suggests the reverse. Aligning with a higher European carbon price and subordinating energy decisions to EU institutions would lock in the very cost burdens the paper identifies as already damaging competitiveness and living standards. Britain’s energy-intensive sectors have already shrunk under the existing tax regime; further upward pressure on carbon costs would accelerate that decline.
The practical alternative is straightforward. Abolish the Climate Change Levy, Carbon Price Support and UK ETS. Reject ETS linkage and electricity-market reintegration. Do not proceed with a UK CBAM that protects neither closed industries nor remaining manufacturers. Use part of the resulting growth dividend, together with targeted reductions in Net Zero spending, to manage the fiscal impact and begin lowering Fuel Duty over time.
Energy policy should prioritise affordable, reliable supply and the competitiveness of the industries that still form the backbone of the economy. Not Zero shows that the current suite of green taxes is achieving the opposite. Andy Burnham’s EU Reset would entrench those taxes at a higher level and surrender the ability to reverse them. That is a poor bargain for British households and businesses.
David Turver writes the Eigen Values Substack page. His new paper for the Prosperity Institute, ‘Not Zero: How Green Taxes Put British Energy Bills in the Red‘, can be downloaded here.




Couldn’t agree more. It’s time to abandon the entire Net Zero agenda, not simply tinker around the edges.
It has been a costly disaster, with ordinary families and businesses left paying the price through higher energy bills, carbon taxes and an increasingly unaffordable cost of living.
We need common sense, affordable and reliable energy, and policies grounded in economic reality rather than political virtue signalling.
Enough is enough. Scrap Net Zero, scrap punitive carbon taxes, and put people and prosperity first.
This article says that PART of the cost problem is self inflicted. Actually ALL of this problem and every other climate related problem is wholly self inflicted. Reason is of course that carbon dioxide regardless of its source does not cause global warming or climate change in the first place. It is a scientific impossibility. Nor is there even one shred of supporting evidence to suggest that it does. That is what we should be writing about. This article, together with many other similar articles, whilst well meaning are actually totally irrelevant. When on earth are people going to waken up to what is actually going on?