This is a fourth article about the Lancet Countdown report’s data torture. In this episode, we look at the report’s claims about wildfires. The issue of wildfires has come up fairly regularly on these pages, because it is the tendency of automata in newsrooms across the planet to link every outbreak to catastrophic anthropogenic climate change. Yet observational evidence suggests otherwise: the global burned area has in fact diminished in recent decades, contrary to alarmists’ prognostications.
“The intensity of extreme weather events such as wildfires, flooding and hurricanes is increasing due to climate change,” claims the report at the head of its section on “health and extreme weather-related events”.
We know that these claims are not true. And we can know that climate science knows they’re not true. On hurricanes, the IPCC states it plainly: “There is low confidence in most reported long-term (multi-decadal to centennial) trends in [tropical cyclone] frequency- or intensity-based metrics”. The data on Accumulated Cyclone Energy (ACE) compiled by meteorologist Dr Ryan Maue at the Climate Atlas further punctures claims that such storms are increasing in their frequency and intensity. And the IPCC is similarly down on flooding:
Attributing changes in heavy precipitation to anthropogenic activities (Section 11.4.4) cannot be readily translated to attributing changes in floods to human activities, because precipitation is only one of the multiple factors, albeit an important one, that affect floods.
Furthermore, according to the IPCC WGI’s table summarising scientific evidence of climate impact drivers (Table 12.12, pg. 1,856), evidence of an anthropogenic influence on river or coastal floods, storms and tropical cyclones (hurricanes), or ‘fire weather’, will not emerge in the data this century, even under extreme future emissions scenarios. (Readers will remember that my Daily Sceptic colleague Chris Morrison has been reporting on the IPCC retiring its categorically alarmist and “implausible” scenarios this year.)




